TheHealthBoard is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn a commission. Learn more.

Athletic Greens Vs. Green Vibrance: Which Is Better?

Choosing between Athletic Greens and Green Vibrance hinges on your health goals and dietary preferences. Athletic Greens boasts a comprehensive blend of vitamins and probiotics, while Green Vibrance focuses on digestive health with a robust nutrient profile. Consider what your body needs most. Curious about which one aligns with your wellness journey? Dive deeper to discover the perfect green supplement for you.
Editorial Team
Editorial Team
Athletic Greens vs. Green Vibrance

Athletic Greens and Green Vibrance are both sought-after formulas on the super greens market, although each of them is compositionally different and provides consumers with different health benefits. These two formulas are designed to help athletes, celebrities, and those looking to take care of their bodies. 

In this review, we are going to explain why these two supplements are revered in the market, and we are going to break down the pros and cons of Athletic Greens vs. Green Vibrance. We will also be exploring which supplement is best suited for your specific needs.

We are also comparing Athletic Greens vs. Green Vibrance to give more context than other online reviews from sites familiar with greens powders. We will break down the different features for each supplement that may influence the decision of which super green to use and invest in. 

Quick Facts

Athletic Greens

Green Vibrance

Health Claims

Athletic Greens are made using 75 high-quality ingredients that are designed to work together. They boost user energy without having any harmful ingredients.

Green Vibrance is made to support a person's digestion, immunity, and circulation.

Ingredients

Athletic Greens tends to have around 75 different vitamins, whole food sourced nutrients, minerals, probiotics, or adaptogens.

Green Vibrance tends to have wheatgrass, spirulina, beetroot, and other probiotics.

Cost

$80-$120 per month.

$80 for 2 months.

Taste

Athletic Greens has been assigned the label of being an acquired taste, with some loving it and others finding it a bad but drinkable beverage that tastes like leafy greens.

Green Vibrance has been described as having a grassy and peppery flavor.

Third-Party Testing

Athletic Greens is NSF Certified for Sport—an independent third-party testing standard that confirms the accuracy of a product's label. This verifies product purity and a lack of contaminants and banned substances.

Vibrant Health Green Vibrance is third-party tested once a product is finished. The product is only released if it can pass the third-party test.

Service Size & Directions

12 grams serving size. Add one scoop to 5-10 ounces of cold water.

11.26 grams serving size. One scoop in cold water.

Safety & Side Effects

Those who take Athletic Greens have reported a different pee color, some digestive issues, constipation, etc.

Some varieties of Green Vibrance contain vanilla powder with trace amounts of milk and soy; therefore, individuals sensitive to these two ingredients should take note.

USDA Organic

There is no USDA certification despite being produced by an NSF-registered facility.

Green Vibrance is USDA organic but not USDA certified.

Money-back Guarantee

Athletic Greens has a 90-day money-back guarantee.

Green Vibrance has a 100% money-back guarantee.

Made in the USA

Athletic Greens are produced in New Zealand, not the USA.

Green Vibrance is manufactured by a Connecticut-based supplement company in the US.

Athletic Greens

Athletic Greens

Athletic Greens is an extremely popular super greens formula within the health and wellbeing market. The formula’s popularity is growing exponentially year over year due to the positive feedback from not only real customers but from athletes, celebrities, and fitness influencers too. 

Packed with over 70 impressive all-natural ingredients, including a wide range of whole food super greens as well as probiotics, prebiotics, adaptogens, and enzymes, it’s not difficult to see why this formula attracts so many people at an initial glance.

Pros

Cons

Contains 75 healthy ingredients, including prebiotics, probiotics, enzymes, and adaptogen.

Made using proprietary blends (no fully disclosed list of ingredients), which shows a lack of transparency.

Vegan-friendly, gluten-free, sugar-free, and nut-free, removing many allergy risks.

More expensive than other formulas on average, per serving.

Easily dissolvable!


Popular with an abundance of athletes, celebrities, and fitness influencers.


Green Vibrance

Green Vibrance

Green Vibrance by Vibrant Health has been on the market since 1992 and has won the highest number of prestigious awards for its brilliance as a healthy formula. This brand has not only been in business so long, but it’s also the most awarded greens supplement on the market, which shows just how reliable the formula is. 

Green Vibrance also contains over 70 ingredients, including potent super greens ingredients, fruits, enzymes, probiotics, prebiotics, herbs, extracts, and more.

Pros

Cons

Over 70 fully-disclosed ingredients that include potent super greens.

Not a sufficient quantity of every single ingredient, which can lead to Green Vibrance not delivering the necessary nutrients.

Highly sought after and acclaimed. Green Vibrance has been winning awards since 1992.

Although you can get different flavors of the formula, the original one does taste grassy, with a less than desirable taste.

Low cost!


Transparent materials.


Athletic Greens vs. Green Vibrance Benefits

There are benefits to integrating a greens powder in your daily diet, and between Athletic Greens and Green Vibrance - there are many differences.

Athletic Greens Benefits

Athletic Greens has gone to the effort of dedicating an entire part of their website to the benefits of the formula. They have been transparent with the list of benefits that each ingredient will provide.

Athletic Greens’ transparency in regards to the specific health benefits of each ingredient, as well as the claims that the athletic greens brand makes about the formula, makes it incredibly attractive. They claim that athletic greens will boost the immune system, protect cells from radical damage, support the digestive system, reduce stress levels, and enhance nutrient absorption.

But there is a significant issue in regards to Athletic Greens’ transparency, or lack thereof, in regards to the amount of each ingredient in a serving. It’s particularly strange that the brand has suspiciously chosen to go into so much detail about the benefits of each ingredient but has not disclosed information regarding the amounts of each ingredient.

Green Vibrance Benefits

Green Vibrance is designed to help the user with whole-body wellness due to the health benefits they state are in the formula. These health benefits are built around the four pillars of health wellness—nutrition, circulation, digestion, and immunity. 

The brand claims that the formula will help the body to function in the most efficient way possible, increase energy levels and boost the immune system. 

There are three ingredients highlighted for their impressive health benefits—probiotics, wheatgrass, and spirulina. The billions of probiotics support digestion and transport nutrients. The wheatgrass detoxifies, alkalizes, and supports the immune system. The spirulina provides protein and increases immunity.

The way Athletic Greens displays the formula’s health benefits is far more transparent and provides more clarity, but it’s unclear whether these health benefits will actually exist because the formula is made using proprietary blends.

Try the supergreens powder we recommend!

Athletic Greens vs. Green Vibrance Ingredients

Ingredients can make or break the quality of greens powders, here are the key ingredients and how they can affect your daily intake of nutrients. 

Athletic Greens Ingredients

Athletic Greens

Contains 75 healthy ingredients, including prebiotics, probiotics, enzymes, and adaptogen. The formula is vegan, gluten-free, nut-free, dairy-free, keto-friendly, paleo-friendly, and non-GMO, making it suitable for a wide range of people with food-specific allergies. 

According to Athletic Greens, their list of ingredients is really impressive and really nutritious, but unfortunately, proprietary blends are used in the formula. 

Proprietary blends are a unique preparation of ingredients in a dietary supplement that is formulated for a specific purpose, typically to help with the form, nutritional value, or taste of a dietary supplement. Most of the time, when it comes to brands using proprietary blends, a majority of the ingredients won’t be sufficiently weighted to provide the health benefits the brand claims the formula will. This means that proprietary blends make any information about a dietary supplement unreliable.

With Athletic Greens, even though we can’t see the exact amount of each ingredient, proprietary blends exist in large amounts, and therefore there is less of a worry of the formula being inaccurate. There might actually be a sufficient amount of ingredients within this formula.

Green Vibrance Ingredients

Green Vibrance Supplement Facts

Green Vibrance contains over 70 ingredients, just like the Athletic Greens formula. Containing everything from super greens and probiotics to herbs and enzymes, the formula is vegan, gluten-free, dairy-free, and non-GMO. 

It’s not quite as allergy-proof as Athletic Greens, and the formula as a whole isn’t certified organic. However, a large proportion of the ingredients within the formula are certified organic, which is a bonus, and Green Vibrance ingredients are not proprietary blends. 

So, unlike Athletic Greens, the Green Vibrance ingredients list is fully disclosed and shows the amount of every ingredient within the formula. This means that the consumer can not only figure out how much of each ingredient they’re consuming, but they can also figure out whether the green powder supplement has the green veggies they may want! This also makes modifying the formula more safe and plausible. And it allows the consumer the ability to research the ingredients and really decide whether Green Vibrance is a formula they wish to put into their bodies.

For instance, Spirulina is always a good super greens ingredient to look at for a green drink, and with a daily recommended dose of between 1-3g, the 600mg within this formula doesn’t quite cut it. So, if you want Spirulina to be a part of your super greens daily dose, Green Vibrance may not be the specific super green for you. However, if you consumed two servings, you could reach the low end of the daily dose recommendation. 

This is true for an array of ingredients within the formula, and although this might seem disappointing, at least the consumer knows how much they’re actually consuming, so they can double up if needed.

Try the supergreens powder we recommend!

Athletic Greens vs. Green Vibrance Taste

It’s not enough that it’s healthy - in order for us to take anything everyday it has to taste great! So what do these greens taste like?

Athletic Greens Taste

Athletic Greens is naturally sweetened using stevia extract, and it’s also flavored using papaya, broccoli powder, cherry powder, carrot, natural pineapple flavor, and natural vanilla flavor. There are a lot of flavorings used to alter the taste of this formula to mixed results. 

While some love the subtle taste of the flavorings and the refreshing nature of the formula, others despise how it tastes. However, the flavor is rarely overpowering, and the formula mixes well, leading to there being no grit when the formula settles.

Green Vibrance Taste

Green Vibrance is available in three flavors: original, chocolate coconut, and matcha tea.

The original flavor contains a flavoring ingredient known as Vanifolia. The chocolate coconut flavor uses natural caramel chocolate coconut flavoring, monk fruit, cocoa powder, and the Vanifolia natural flavoring. The matcha tea flavor simply contains monk fruit extract, vanilla natural flavoring, and the basic Vanifolia natural flavoring. 

The formula is commonly reviewed as having a grass-like taste, but it’s easy to drink and mixes well also. 

Athletic Greens vs. Green Vibrance Cost

Which is more affordable? The answer is completely subjective, but here’s a breakdown of the cost between Athletic Greens and Green Vibrance.

Athletic Greens Cost

Athletic Greens is one of the more expensive super greens formulas on the market, making it unaffordable for a lot of people. A 30-day serving pouch of Athletic Greens can cost anywhere from $80-$120, depending on the method of purchasing used. The average cost a month is $97, which works out at a cost per serving of $3.23. 

This is much more expensive than other super greens formulas on the market, which is especially concerning due to it containing proprietary blends.

If you are set on having this formula, you can choose to subscribe to the product and save around 20% in terms of payment. If you did this, the cost per serving would be closer to the average for super greens formulas and would immediately seem more reasonable.

Green Vibrance Cost

Green Vibrance is relatively low cost compared to Athletic Greens and many other super green formulas. One tub of 30-servings (337.8g) Green Vibrance costs $56.00 on average. This works out at a cost per serving of $1.86. 

If you pay for multiple months, you can get a 60-serving Green Vibrance for $80, which is even cheaper on average. If you subscribe to the formula, you can save 20% and get free shipping. This works out at a cost per serving of $1.49 or lower, depending on how large of a serving you purchase. 

Regardless, the costs are significantly cheaper than Athletic Greens, even though both of the formulas have a very similar serving size and a similar number of ingredients.

Try the supergreens powder that’s worth every penny!

Athletic Greens vs. Green Vibrance: Which Is Better?

In terms of the number of ingredients, the average grams per serving, and the methods of attaining the super green, I’d have to say that these two formulas are pretty close to one another. 

The core differences come in the price difference, which definitely favors Green Vibrance, the gluten-free healthy nature of each formula, which slightly favors Athletic Greens, and the proprietary nature of Athletic Greens ingredients, which makes Green Vibrance far more transparent. 

For most individuals, Green Vibrance is the more transparent, reliable, and cheaper option. However, for those with certain allergies that Athletic Greens won’t activate but Green Vibrance will, Athletic Greens are a solid alternative.

Additionally, if you are looking for the best athletic greens alternatives, there are a few other options available in the market. These alternatives offer similar benefits to Athletic Greens and can be a great option for those looking for a different taste or price point.

Why We Recommend Live it Up Super Greens Instead

Live it Up have proven to be of great value to people who work longer hours and adults who are in danger of developing preventable illnesses. And this is why we strongly recommend Live it Up Super Greens. We believe Live it Up is the best green powder to support your immune system and improve your body’s health.

Live it Up makes avoiding this a breeze by taking nature's best and providing it to you in the easiest form possible. 

You pair that with the fact that Live it Up are incredibly affordable, with high-quality probiotic and enzyme blends, as well as Live it Up’ ability to be used with almond milk to make smoothies, and it becomes clear how much more utility Live it Up offers at such an affordable price.

Get 15% Off with WISEGEEK15

Live it Up creates formulas designed to improve your body's health & support your immune system. Key benefits of Live it Up blends:

  • Certified organic ingredients 
  • Commitment to all-natural ingredients
  • Organic and energizing superfoods
  • 100% plant-based and vegan friendly
  • Commitment to non-GMO ingredients
  • Gluten friendly
  • No dairy
  • No soy
  • No artificial flavors, sweeteners, fillers, or added sugars
  • Made in the United States

We all grew up hearing about how important it is to include greens in our nutrition, but still, too many people do not consume nearly the required amount for healthy living. This lack of fruit and vegetable intake increases the risk of several chronic diseases, including cardiovascular disease, type 2 diabetes, some cancers, and obesity. Live it Up Super Greens is by no means a band-aid solution, it’s a step towards optimal health. 

Try the supergreens powder we recommend!

Other Superfood Brand Comparison Reviews:

About the author
Editorial Team
Editorial Team
Our Editorial Team, made up of seasoned professionals, prioritizes accuracy and quality in every piece of content. With years of experience in journalism and publishing, we work diligently to deliver reliable and well-researched content to our readers.